When a shareholder sends a replacement proxy before a meeting, retain both instruments and ask the authorised meeting officer to determine which applies. Receipt of a newer document should not prompt staff to erase the earlier appointment or assume the legal result.

Hands signing a document at an office desk
Illustrative photograph by Pavel Danilyuk.

Log each instrument separately

Record the sender, holder, holding, appointed proxy, signature information, receipt time and delivery channel. Match the documents to the same meeting and identify any differences in scope or voting instructions. Preserve the original files.

Check the company's constitution, notice and applicable law with the secretary. The process for accepting an appointment, its timing and the effect of a replacement or revocation need review against the actual documents. An internal spreadsheet deadline is not a complete legal analysis.

Escalate the competing instructions

Give the secretary or designated meeting officer a short chronology and the complete instruments. Explain whether the newer message expressly revokes the old appointment or merely attaches another form. Do not contact a disputed recipient through an unverified address supplied in the same message.

For example, the first form appoints a named person and the second appoints the chair. Keep each receipt timestamp and ask for a recorded acceptance decision. A staff member should not resolve the issue by selecting whichever form arrived in their own inbox last.

Record the accepted outcome

Update the meeting list only after the authorised decision. Show which instrument was accepted and who made the determination. Retain rejected or superseded documents as history with controlled access.

If the issue remains open when attendance or voting records are prepared, flag it clearly. Avoid counting both appointments, inventing a revocation time or describing the replacement as valid solely because the file name says “final”.

Related practical guidance

For the surrounding records and responsibilities, see maintaining statutory records, the company secretary role, company recordkeeping.

Official guidance: ACRA company guidance.

Help with your company records

For corporate secretarial and company administration support, contact Raffles Corporate Services at [email protected] or WhatsApp +65 8501 7133. Tell us which records or process need attention so we can discuss the relevant next steps.